Cricut Cut Settings-Fix bad cuts fast!

Some links in this post are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you choose to buy—at no extra cost to you. I only share products I genuinely use or recommend.

If there’s one Cricut struggle I see daily, it’s this:
“I’m using the recommended setting… so why isn’t it cutting?!”

Here’s the truth: material settings are a starting point, not a guarantee. Brands vary, thickness varies, humidity varies—so your goal is to get a clean cut for the material you actually have, not the one Cricut imagined.

Let’s make it easy.

The Best Way to Choose a Cut Setting

1. Start with the closest material in Design Space

2. Run a small test cut (a tiny- but not too tiny square/circle)

3. Adjust one thing at a time until it’s perfect

That’s it. That’s the whole secret.

The 30-Second Checklist Before You Blame the Setting

Before you change pressure, check these first:

• Material fully adhered to the mat? (Brayer it)

• Correct mat grip for the material? (I have a post on that!)

• Blade clean + fully seated?

• Material flat (no curl or bubbles)?

• Cutting on a stable surface (no wobble)?

Fixing any one of these often solves the problem immediately.

Quick Adjustments

If it’s NOT cutting through

Try in this order:

1. Brayer again + re-load straight

2. Clean blade housing (paper dust builds up fast)

3. Select More Pressure

4. Choose a slightly heavier setting (example: Cardstock+ instead of Cardstock)

5. Replace the blade if it’s been a while

If it’s cutting THROUGH the backing (stickers/vinyl)

Try in this order:

1. Select Less Pressure

2. Choose a lighter setting

3. Double-check you didn’t select a cardstock setting by accident

If it’s tearing/shredding paper

Try in this order:

1. Less Pressure

2. Use a lighter cardstock/paper setting

3. Swap to a fresh blade

4. Switch cardstock (some textured brands shred easier)

The Most Common “Uneven Cut” Problem (Some Spots Cut, Others Don’t)

If your cut looks perfect in some spots and barely cut in others, it’s usually one of these:

• Debris on the mat (tiny scraps create raised pressure spots)

• Mat is worn/warped (try a different mat)

• Material isn’t fully stuck down (brayer + tape corners if needed)

• Blade is dull or housing is dirty

• Table flex (your machine needs a stable surface)

This is why brayer + a clean mat fixes so much.

A Simple Rule of Thumb

• Tearing/shredding = too much pressure or dull blade

• Not cutting through = too little pressure, debris, or poor adhesion

• Always change one thing at a time, then test cut

Print Then Cut Note

If you’re doing Print Then Cut, always print at:

• 100% scale (no “fit to page”)

• Use System Dialog if printer settings won’t stick
  And calibrate if cuts are off.

Want Help Troubleshooting Your Cut?

Join Cricut Tips & Tricks on Facebook and post:

• your machine (Explore/Maker/Joy)

• material + brand

• what setting you used

• a photo of the cut result

You’ll get better answers faster when we can see what’s happening.